LAHINCH, County Clare — The first match out of the gate on Saturday morning is a rerun. Stuart Grehan and Eliot Baker against Preston Stout and Ethan Fang: the exact same four men, in the exact same format, who played each other in the opening session at Cypress Point twelve months ago. GB&I won that one, 1 up.
Dean Robertson did not have to do that. He could have hidden his local hero, or split a pairing that has been picked apart in the year since. Instead he put Grehan and Baker back on the first tee and pointed them at the world No. 1. Nathan Smith, for his part, has now sent Stout and Fang out as a foursomes duo for the third time — after they went 0-2 together at Cypress Point.
Both captains are making a point. And underneath both points sits one number that explains this entire match better than any world ranking will.
The number: GB&I won the foursomes at Cypress Point
Pull last September apart and it looks nothing like a 17-9 hammering.
Foursomes: GB&I 5, USA 3. The visitors took Saturday morning 3-1 and split Sunday morning 2-2.
Singles: USA 14, GB&I 4. Out of eighteen.
That is the whole story of the 50th Walker Cup, and nobody wants to say it out loud because it ruins the nicest cliché in the sport. Foursomes is supposed to be the great equalizer — the session where partnership and links craft beat a shiny ranking. Fine. GB&I equalized. It cost the Americans two points and bought GB&I nothing, because the Walker Cup awards eighteen singles points and only eight in alternate shot. You can sweep the equalizer and still lose by eight. They did.
This is not a one-off, either. In 2023 at St Andrews, GB&I took the opening foursomes 3-1 and led 7½-4½ after Day 1 — their joint-best opening day since 1989 — and lost 14½-11½, with the U.S. taking ten of the fourteen points available on Sunday. In 2019 at Royal Liverpool, GB&I led 7-5 and lost by five. Three matches, three fast starts, three defeats.
So the question at Lahinch is not whether Grehan can beat Stout in alternate shot. He has already done that. The question is what happens at two o'clock, when the pairs break up and eight men walk to the first tee alone.
What the two empty chairs tell you
Both captains left a marquee name out of the opening session, and both decisions are more interesting than they first look.
Smith sits William Jennings, the world No. 4. Golfweek reported that Jennings, Stout and Fang all missed Thursday's practice round with stomach illness and were still being managed carefully into Friday. Sitting the man who has seen the least of the golf course is the conservative call, and Smith can afford conservative — he has seven of the world's top twelve.
Robertson sits Jack Whaley, and that one is a choice, not a precaution. Whaley is the reigning U.S. Amateur champion, the third Englishman ever to win it after Harold Hilton and Matt Fitzpatrick, and he got there by beating Jay Leng Jr. 4&3 at Merion. Leng tees off in Match 2 on Saturday morning. Whaley watches.
Read that alongside the Cypress Point math and the logic is obvious. Robertson is not spending his U.S. Amateur champion on the session GB&I already wins. He is saving him for the sessions GB&I keeps losing. The same reasoning applies to Ben Bolton, the other man sitting — a debutant who played the South of Ireland here in July and now gets a full morning to watch how the golf course is behaving before anyone hands him a scorecard.
Five predictions
1. GB&I wins Saturday morning foursomes again — call it 2½-1½
They have taken the Day 1 foursomes session in each of the last two matches, they are running two intact winning pairings from Cypress Point back out, and they are doing it on a golf course where Grehan has played an estimated thirty to forty rounds. Lahinch punishes the player who has to think. Blind tee shots over the Klondyke, a green you cannot see at the Dell, humpback fairways that reject a good shot for no reason a launch monitor would accept — every one of those is worth more to the man who has stood there before than to the man ranked eleven spots higher. Alternate shot doubles the value of that knowledge, because only one of you has to have it.
2. And it still won't decide anything
Since the format expanded in 2009 to send all ten players out on Sunday afternoon, the closing singles session has decided every Walker Cup. USA went 8½-1½ in it at Cypress Point. They took ten of fourteen across Sunday at St Andrews after trailing by three. Whatever the scoreboard reads at Saturday dinner, this match is settled between roughly 1:30 and 6 p.m. Irish time on Sunday — and GB&I needs somewhere near nine of the eighteen singles points to reach 13½. They managed four last year.
3. Stout and Fang lose again in the morning — and Stout still finishes as the USA's leading scorer
The split in Stout's Cypress Point record is the most useful thing on either team sheet. In foursomes alongside Fang: 0-2. In singles: 2-0, including a 6&5 dismantling of Charlie Forster and the 2&1 win over Luke Poulter that clinched the Cup. Alternate shot asks a great player to trust someone else's misses; singles asks him only to be better, which he usually is. Expect the pattern to hold, expect the morning result to generate a lot of noise about American vulnerability, and expect Stout to make that noise look silly by Sunday afternoon.
4. Stewart Hagestad, benched Saturday morning, plays every singles session and wins them both
He is 7-1 in Walker Cup singles across six appearances and has never been on a losing side. At Cypress Point he beat Gavin Tiernan 7&5 and Eliot Baker 4&3. He is comfortably the oldest man in the match on a team whose average age is roughly nineteen, he has played more competitive links golf than most of the American roster combined, and he is the one U.S. player whose game does not care what the wind does. If the weather turns, he becomes the most valuable man here. Smith knows it, which is exactly why he is not spending him on an 8:30 a.m. alternate-shot lottery.
5. Tyler Weaver is GB&I's swing variable, and this is the year it swings
Weaver went out twice in singles at Cypress Point and lost twice, both times to Jackson Koivun, 4&3 and 3&2. Koivun is not here. Weaver is now world No. 3, the highest-ranked player on the home side, and he arrives with a specific grudge and no specific tormentor. He also has the thing that travels best on a links: his foursomes partnership with Connor Graham took down the world No. 1 pairing last September, and Robertson has kept it together. If Weaver goes 2-0 in singles, GB&I are in this to the last hour. If he goes 0-2 again, they are not.
The pick
USA 14, GB&I 12. Not because the Americans are better in match play — they are simply better, and seven of the world's top twelve is not a rounding error. GB&I's path exists and it is narrow: all but two of their nine wins have come at home, the last of them at Royal Lytham in 2015, and the last away win was Ocean Forest in 2001. Home links is the whole plan.
The one thing that turns this prediction over is weather, and it is not close. A firm, blowing Lahinch is the best friend GB&I have — variance is an underdog's currency, and this golf course generates more of it than anywhere the match has been played in twenty years. A soft, still Lahinch is a birdie contest, and a birdie contest against that American roster is a formality. Jon Rahm shot 62 here in 2019 and Robert Rock shot 60. That is what a calm Lahinch gives away.
If it blows: GB&I 13½, USA 12½, and County Clare does not sleep for a week.
There is precedent for the wilder version, and it happens to be the best Walker Cup Sunday GB&I ever had. At St Andrews in 1971 they won all four opening foursomes, watched the Americans take six of eight singles to lead after Day 1, fell two behind after Sunday's alternate shot — and then won six of the last eight singles to take the Cup 13-11. The comeback exists. It just has to come from the session GB&I have spent a decade losing.
Live scores, the full draw, tee times and TV listings all weekend: the 2026 Walker Cup coverage hub.
More from Lahinch:
