After struggling to a 5-over 77 in the first round of stroke play on Saturday, White, the 2024 R&A Senior Amateur champion, has slowly begun to figure things out on the demanding Pete Dye layout that has been made even more challenging with temperatures reaching into the high 90s and firm greens running 13 feet on the Stimpmeter. On Tuesday, the 2015 U.S. Amateur Four-Ball champion played the equivalent of 5-under-par golf, with the usual match-play concessions.

In the afternoon, he was playing a highly motivated Newsom, an ophthalmic surgeon who in the past five years has reached the finals (2019), semifinals (2023) and quarterfinals (2022). Last year, he lost to White, 2 and 1, and has repeatedly said how much he wants to win this title.

But White never let him into the match, seizing control midway through with a winning par on No. 8, a 12-foot birdie on 9, a winning par on the 11th and another birdie on 12 to go 5 up. This came after he hit his tee shot into the penalty area on the 268-yard, seventh hole and eventually conceded an eagle 2 to Newsom. 

“It’s great to be in the final eight and to have an opportunity,” said White, who planned to call in his lesson plan to his substitute teacher for Wednesday’s classes before enjoying dinner and a good night’s rest. “That’s all anybody can ask for is an opportunity and that’s what I have tomorrow morning.

“Todd Burgan played incredibly well [in the Round of 32]. I am up there on [hole] 17 and have 9 feet for eagle. He is short of the green and the worst-case scenario is I am going to halve this hole and we are going to be fine. And then to see the ball disappear when he chips it in, and then I just didn’t quite hit my putt hard enough. I knew when I teed it up this afternoon that I had to bring my best game when you’re playing against Roger [Newsom]. He’s an incredible competitor and incredible gentleman.”

It turned out to be a tough afternoon in the sun for the two co-medalists. John Kemp, 56, of England, the No. 1 seed who posted 2-under 142 in qualifying alongside Newsom, had his championship run ended by Bunker on the 19th hole. Kemp, who manages a packaging business, was constantly playing from behind against the retired middle-school physical-education teacher/basketball coach who spends winters in Venice, Fla.

He eventually tied the match with a birdie on the par-3 16th, then made a remarkable up-and-down par on No. 18 from 6 feet to force extra holes. It was the second time in two days he was extended beyond the 18th. But unlike his 23-hole win on Monday, Kemp wound up making bogey and conceding Bunker’s 5-foot birdie putt. Bunker had hit a gap wedge out of a fairway bunker from 129 yards.

This is Bunker’s second appearance in the quarterfinals, having lost three years ago to Jerry Gunthorpe at the Country Club of Detroit. Earlier in the day, he eliminated the other Englishman to make match play, Stephen Creed, 5 and 3.

Dave Bunker

“I have had a couple of injuries the last two years that kind of held me back a bit,” said Bunker of his Achilles tear and meniscus in his right knee. “I feel good and healthy now and I am swinging really well. It’s nice to play good golf.”

Both Sughrue and Sullivan have been on cruise control in match play. Sughrue, a quarterfinalist for the fourth time in seven U.S. Senior Amateur starts, including a runner-up finish in 2016 at Old Warson Country Club in St. Louis, Mo., has only trailed for one hole over the 51 he’s played since Monday’s opening round.

That includes his 5-and-4 win in the Round of 32 over 2014 runner-up Bryan Norton, of Overland Park, Kan., (he lost the opening hole), and the 3-and-1 decision over Tim Dunlavey, of Spartanburg, S.C., in the Round of 16.

Against Dunlavey, Sughrue saw a 5-up lead whittled to one after making a double bogey on the 15th hole. Then Sughrue, a family marriage therapist and sports performance mental coach, hit what he called two of the best shots of his competitive career on 16 and 17. He nearly holed out on the par-3 16th with a 7-iron from 180 yards that led to a winning birdie, and on the par-5 17th, he perfectly executed a 5-iron cut shot from 195 yards up the hill to 30 feet that eventually was conceded for eagle.

Sullivan has not trailed since the fifth hole of his first-round match against Philip Josephson, a span of 40 holes. He’s coming off a win in the Southern California Golf Association’s Senior Match Play Championship and a runner-up showing in the Lupton Memorial at The Honors Course this past spring. On Tuesday, he dispatched David Tassell, of Jupiter, Fla., 4 and 3, and Jon Brown, of Adel, Iowa, 3 and 2. He’ll next face Bunker in the first quarterfinal match on Wednesday.

Dan Sullivan

Whitacre qualified for his first USGA championship two years ago at The Kittansett Club, and even though he missed match play by three strokes, he loved every minute of the experience. A talk with Scott Simpson, the 1987 U.S. Open champion who he befriended while serving as actor/comedian Bill Murray’s caddie during the annual AT&T National Pro-Am at Pebble Beach, helped put Whitacre at ease about playing in a USGA event.

Whitacre grew up in Carmel, Calif. (he went to Carmel High and played at Monterey Peninsula Community College before transferring to the University of Illinois) and caddied at famed Pebble Beach Golf Links, site of six U.S. Opens. Through his mom and George Peper, a golf author and publisher, he landed Murray’s bag in the AT&T Pro-Am, winning the title in 2011 with pro D.A. Points, a fellow Illinois alum.

Whitacre still remains close to Murray and the two have exchanged texts this week as he’s made his way through the draw. Tuesday, he gutted out a pair of 1-up wins over Mike Finster, of Saint Petersburg, Fla., and 1996 U.S. Amateur Public Links champion Tim Hogarth, of Northridge, Calif.

Trailing by a hole going into the par-4 ninth, Whitacre won Nos. 9 and 10 with pars, and then the two foes tied the remaining eight holes. That included a remarkable up-and-down par by Hogarth on No. 17 (15-footer after leaving his first bunker shot in the sand) and Whitacre returning the favor on the 18th, hitting a delicate pitch from just left of the green to a foot for a conceded par. Hogarth had already missed his 30-foot birdie attempt.

“You gotta have a really good short game, that was the big thing,” said Whitacre of what he learned from his first U.S. Senior Amateur. “You need to develop a mental approach to the game. I have worked hard on that too.”

Knecht, a property manager, has enjoyed quite a love affair with The Honors Course. Before this week’s championship, the father of two aced the par-3 14th hole in back-to-back years with the same club (8-iron) at the same distance (148 yards). He did not have any holes-in-one on Tuesday, but he did produce two wins to make his first quarterfinal, defeating Jerry Achilles, of Georgetown, Texas, 4 and 3, and 1997 U.S. Mid-Amateur runner-up Rick Stimmel, of Pittsburgh, Pa., in the Round of 16, 4 and 2.

Mark Knecht

Brown, a former tour and club professional competing in his third U.S. Senior Amateur, had the largest margin of victory in the Round of 16, a 6-and-5 decision over left-hander Paul Smith, of Ventura, Calif. Earlier on Tuesday, the former University of Georgia standout outlasted fellow Georgian, Jack Hall, of Savannah, 2 up. Hall was coming off a 25-hole win on Monday afternoon in the Round of 64.

Another decorated Georgian was not so fortunate. Bob Royak, the 2019 champion and 2023 semifinalist from Alpharetta, saw his championship ended by Nelson. Four years ago, Nelson was ousted in the opening round by 2015 champion Chip Lutz. He got a rematch with Lutz in the Round of 32, this time producing a 1-up victory before taking out another past champion in the Round of 16, 2 and 1.

“That’s full day in that heat,” said Nelson, who works in the health care industry. “I started getting a little wobbly legged on the back nine, but we held it together. That guy (Bob Royak) is a stud. I played him before in some Southeastern Challenge Cup matches and I knew he was a great player. I knew I had it in me. I just needed to play my game and fortunately I did.”

It doesn’t get any easier for Nelson. Next up is yet another USGA champion: Todd White

What’s Next

Match play continues on Wednesday with the quarterfinals and semifinals, starting at 7:30 a.m. EDT. The semifinal matches are scheduled to begin at 1 p.m. and 1:15 p.m. Thursday’s 18-hole championship match is scheduled for 8:30 a.m. The winner and runner-up both receive exemptions into the 2025 U.S. Senior Open Championship at The Broadmoor in Colorado Springs, Colo. Admission is free and spectators are encouraged to attend.