2025 Brian Groff (Sr), Ben Cook (SS)
2024 Jeff Frazier (Sr), James Gavaghan (SS)
2023 Rick Stimmel (Sr), Brian Rothaus (SS)
2022 David Blichar (Sr), Duke Delcher (SS)
2021 David Brown (Sr), Duke Delcher (SS)
2020 Chris Fieger (Sr), Lee Lykens (SS)
2019 Sean Knapp (Sr), Don Donatoni (SS)
2018 Sean Knapp (Sr), Paul Schlachter (SS)
2017 Glenn Smeraglio (Sr), Don Donatoni (SS)
2016 Scott Mayne (Sr), Mike McGuire (SS)
2015 Perry Graciano (Sr), Dave DeNezza (SS)
2014 Robin McCool (Sr), Don Donatoni (SS)
2013 Robin McCool (Sr), Lee Lykens (SS)
2012 Paul Schlachter (Sr), Ed Hennigan (SS)
2011 John Rodney (Sr), Jay Howson, Jr. (SS)
2010 Paul Schlachter (Sr), Jay Howson, Jr. (SS)
2009 Dave DeNezza (Sr), Jay Howson, Jr. (SS)
2008 Roc Irey (Sr), Phil Saylor (SS)
2007 Ray Thompson (Sr), Richard A. Smith (SS)
2006 Paul Schlachter (Sr), George Bilowick (SS)
2005 King Knox (Sr), George Bilowick (SS)
2004 Paul Schlachter (Sr), Richard A. Smith (SS)
2003 Ronald Pieczynski (Sr), Warren Deakins (SS)
2002 Herbert Gordon
2001 Ed Hennigan
2000 Jim Wetzel
1999 Bill Baloh
1998 Phil Saylor
1997 Brian Sachs
1996 Jim Anderson
1995 John H. Guenther, Jr.
1994 Rich Jacob
1993 James Keim
1992 Eric Antilla
1991 John Guenther, Jr.
1990 John Guenther, Jr.
1989 Donald Geisler
1988 John Guenther, Jr.
1987 James Amato
1986 Allan Sussel
1985 James H. Dolan
1984 Allan Sussel
1983 William Weik
1982 Dick Kluck
1981 C.R. Shetzer
1980 Joseph F. Durante
1979 Anthony Scalise
1978 William Hyndman, III.
1977 Carl Hardner
1976 Harold F. Billheimer
1975 Russ Maitland
1974 James McArdle
1973 A.J. Jordan
1972 A.J. Jordan
1971 A.J. Jordan
1970 Joseph Higgins
1969 R. Burt Gookin
1968 William R. Burns
1967 W.B. McCullough, Jr.
1966 W.B. McCullough, Jr.
1965 Lee M. Rumsey
1964 Charles A. Totten
1963 Casimer Mohn
1962 William O. Van Tine
1961 P.J. Procario
1960 Egon F. Quittner