The cut for match play was 1-over 142, and 14 competitors played off on Monday morning for the final 12 spots.

Following an overnight thunderstorm that dropped a minimal amount of precipitation on both courses, the competitors were greeted with overcast skies that eventually morphed into afternoon sunshine. Temperatures were in the mid-70s most of the first day of fall.

“At some point, I would like to turn pro,” said Oliva Pinto, who also won the Colonial Athletic Association individual title in 2019 when he competed for the University of North Carolina-Wilmington before transferring to Arkansas in the fall of 2020 for his final three collegiate seasons (including a COVID-19 year). “I want to get my game better first…Just keep improving and get more results. I have no rush right now.”

Instead of entering PGA Tour/Korn Ferry Tour Q-School or chasing paychecks on the mini-tour circuit, Oliva Pinto decided to become an entrepreneur with brother Tobias, two years his senior. Tobias, with an industrial engineering background, and Segundo created Hangry King, a barbecue kit that features a variety of tools “to flex and grill in style,” according to its website. The prototypes have been tested and the two will bring the product to Amazon sometime in November.

That has freed Oliva Pinto up to play as much amateur golf as possible over the past 19 months, including a tie for eighth in the Latin America Amateur Championship this past January in Panama. He also qualified for his second U.S. Amateur, missing the cut at Hazeltine National Golf Club. In 2020, he reached the Round of 16 at Bandon Dunes before a heartbreaking 1-down defeat to eventual champion Tyler Strafaci when his local caddie committed a costly loss-of-hole Rules infraction on the 18th hole.

To prepare for his first U.S. Mid-Amateur, Oliva Pinto won the Argentina Mid-Am, then took the long flight from Buenos Aires to Virginia, where his good form continued.

During Sunday’s second round at Independence Golf Club, a public facility that once housed the Virginia State Golf Association, Oliva Pinto had thoughts of posting a 62 or 63 after making four birdies in a five-hole stretch. It included a 30-footer from the fringe on the 204-yard, par-3 ninth, a pair of 10-footers on Nos. 11 and 12, and a 40-foot “bomb” on the 449-yard 13th hole, the fourth-hardest hole on the course. But a late bogey on 16, a 448-yard, par-4, ended his hopes for a super-low round.

“I am glad to have my game back again,” said Oliva Pinto. “I think I brought my ‘A’ game this week, so I feel like I am in a good place.”

For the second consecutive day, Beck, playing just two hours from home in front of friends and family, posted a first-nine, 5-under 30. But unlike on Saturday when he struggled over his final nine holes, including bogeys on two of his last three holes, he continued to put his foot on the gas pedal, finishing with consecutive birdies on Nos. 17 and 18.

Beck, No. 32 in the World Amateur Golf Ranking®/WAGR®, began his second nine by hitting his tee shot into a penalty area and then holing a clutch 12-foot bogey putt. He recovered with two consecutive birdies before sustaining bogeys on 14 and 15. Sitting at 6 under with two holes to play, the former Wake Forest standout who was the runner-up in the 2008 U.S. Junior Amateur, stuffed an 8-iron from 182 yards to 2 feet on the par-4 17th. Then on the par-5 18th, he crushed a 5-wood from 280 yards into the right-greenside bunker and got up and down for his 4, converting a short 3-footer.

“It’s great. I don’t think I have been a medalist in a USGA event, so that is really cool,” said Beck. “I’ve got a bunch of matches to play so looking at the next one.

“I played really well, hit it close a handful of times. I had nine birdies, and several were kick-ins, which helps and makes it stress free.”

Harvey, a property manager, was hoping to land medalist honors for a fifth time in 15 U.S. Mid-Amateur starts. A 64 on Saturday at Kinloch had the two-time USGA champion – he also captured the 2019 U.S. Amateur Four-Ball title with partner Todd Mitchell – thinking about such a feat. A 40-foot birdie on the par-4 first at Independence continued such thoughts. But it turned out to be a day of scrambling and grinding just to post even-par 70.

“My body just didn’t feel like I could move today,” said Harvey, who has cut back his competitive schedule over the last few years to spend more time with his 15-year-old son, Cameron, an aspiring junior golfer, and 5-year-old son, Gavin, who turns 6 in October. “I’m exhausted. I’m glad I am done…I get to go watch [NFL] football, relax and hydrate. I’m happy to have the whole afternoon to just chill out and relax.”

Butler, a consultant who played collegiately at Villanova University and attended the same high school in Lancaster, Pa., as 2003 U.S. Open champion Jim Furyk (Manheim Township), made the 15-minute drive to Kinloch after completing his first round on Saturday at Independence to get himself acclimated to the bentgrass greens. Independence features bermudagrass throughout, which has a completely different playing characteristic.

He also came to his second U.S. Mid-Amateur – he missed the cut last year – with a different mindset. It was a lesson learned recently at the Pennsylvania Mid-Amateur when he followed a first-round 68 with a 75 in the 36-hole competition. A 3-under 68 after his 66 at Independence demonstrated a lesson properly learned.

“I thought I did a pretty good job,” said Butler of his putting and course management. “I have played a decent amount between PA (Pennsylvania) and the GAP (Golf Association of Philadelphia). Probably more than I should. I am waiting on that [match-play] tee time [on Monday] and figuring out when I can work just to keep things rolling.”

A year ago, Edens, in his third season at the helm of the Jackrabbits’ men’s golf program, had to sweat out a playoff just to make match play after a disastrous bogey-bogey-double bogey finish to stroke play. Once in the draw, however, Edens made a run to the quarterfinals, losing to eventual champion Stewart Hagestad, 2 and 1. No such anxiety occurred this year following a second-round 65 at Kinloch. His lone blemish was a bogey on No. 16, his seventh hole of the day. Otherwise, he played 7-under golf, a performance that would portend well in match play.

“I hit some really good shots and then I made some good putts,” said Edens. “On 5 I was looking at a tree just left of it [the green] and I kind of pushed it at the flag. I told my [local] caddie that’s what I tell my guys [student-athletes]. That’s why we aim at the tree instead of at the flag and miss the green right.”

Three competitors finished at 6-under 135: 2024 U.S. Amateur quarterfinalist/2023 U.S. Mid-Amateur quarterfinalist Bobby Massa, of Dallas, Texas; 2023 U.S. Open qualifier Christian Cavaliere, of Katonah, N.Y.; and Stephen Hale, of Bakersfield, Calif.

First-round co-leader Nick Barrett, a UPS truck driver from Catonsville, Md., posted a 1-over 72 at Kinloch after a career-round 64 on Day 1 at Independence for a 5-under total of 136.

What’s Next

The 14-for-12 playoff for the final spots in the match-play draw will take place at 7:10 a.m. EDT off the 10th tee at Kinloch Golf Club, and then progressing forward, if necessary. The first Round-of-64 match is scheduled for 8 a.m. Match play continues Tuesday and Wednesday, with the 36-hole final set for Thursday. Admission is free and spectators are encouraged to attend.

Notable

Notable competitors in the playoff include 2022 U.S. Mid-Amateur runner-up Hugh Foley; 2024 U.S. Senior Amateur runner-up Daniel Sullivan, 2007 U.S. Amateur Public Links runner-up Cody Paladino; Andrew Paysse, the brother-in-law of two-time Masters champion and world No. 1 Scottie Scheffler; 2024 U.S. Open qualifier/high school science teacher Colin Prater, and former Stanford University tennis player Jack Barber.

Five USGA champions qualified for match play: Scott Harvey (2014 U.S. Mid-Amateur/2019 U.S. Amateur Four-Ball); Chad Wilfong (2022 U.S. Amateur Four-Ball); Brian Blanchard (2024 U.S. Amateur Four-Ball); Stewart Hagestad (2016, 2021, 2023 U.S. Mid-Amateur); and Matthew McClean (2022 U.S. Mid-Amateur). Hagestad carded a 3-under 67 at Independence Golf Club as he looks to be the third player in Mid-Amateur history to capture consecutive titles.

Other notables to make the cut were 2012 U.S. Amateur runner-up/2013 USA Walker Cupper Michael Weaver; Adam Barkow, the son of award-winning golf writer Al Barkow; Jordan Utley, of Richmond, Va., who spent three years as the director of finance at Independence G.C.; three-time USGA runner-up Drew Kittleson (2008 U.S. Amateur, 2022 and 2023 U.S. Amateur Four-Ball); and Argentinian Andres Schonbaum, the Latin and Caribbean manager for The R&A.   

Five U.S. Mid-Amateur champions failed to advance, including four-time winner Nathan Smith, the 2025 USA Walker Cup captain who received a special exemption into the field. Others not qualifying included Matt Parziale (2017), Lukas Michel (2019), Kevin O’Connell (2018) and victorious 2023 USA Walker Cup captain Michael McCoy (2013).

Other notables who did not qualify included two-time USGA champion Todd White (2015 U.S. Amateur Four-Ball/2023 U.S. Senior Amateur); Mark Costanza (2021 U.S. Mid-Amateur runner-up); Ben Warnquist (2016 U.S. Amateur Four-Ball runner-up); Jeronimo Esteve (2023 U.S. Mid-Amateur medalist); Joseph Deraney (2019 U.S. Mid-Amateur runner-up); Rick Stimmel (1997 U.S. Mid-Amateur runner-up), and Sam Engel (2024 U.S. Amateur Four-Ball champion).

John Tyner, of Fairhope, Ala., started and ended poorly at Kinloch on Sunday. In between, he made nine birdies to shoot 67, a seven-stroke improvement from his opening round at Independence G.C., and a spot in the draw at even-par 141. Tyner, a 2015 University of Memphis graduate, bogeyed his opening hole, the par-4 10th, and played 4-over golf over his last three holes. The portfolio manager for Aptus Capital Advisors also made three consecutive birdies from No. 11, and four straight birdies from No. 1.

The stroke averages for both courses were virtually identical: 73.58 for Independence and 73.71 for Kinloch.