How to Build a Better High School Golf Program: Lessons from the Varsity Level
February 14, 2026 | by Kyle Rector of AmateurGolf.com

High school golf is booming — and so is the pressure | AmateurGolf.com Podcast presented by Cobra.
High school golf is booming. Participation is up nationwide, and junior golf pipelines are deeper than ever. But while more kids are playing, the gap between “making the team” and becoming a reliable varsity contributor can feel enormous — especially in nine-hole formats where one mistake can flip a scorecard.
On a recent episode of the AmateurGolf.com Podcast presented by Cobra, we sat down with Andrew Sherman, the varsity golf coach at Templeton High School in Templeton, California. Sherman has helped build local golf pathways through programs like First Tee and PGA Junior League, and he’s watched golfers grow from beginner stages into high school competitors inside a community where course access and peer groups can accelerate development.
The best takeaways from the conversation weren’t about swing positions — they were about culture, stability, and how to coach the players who live on the edge of your top six. Here are the biggest lessons for high school coaches.
1) Stop Coaching the Swing — Start Coaching the Athlete
Most high school golfers already have access to swing tips — coaches, YouTube, friends, and (often) a private instructor. Where programs can truly separate is in building athletes who can handle a season and a multi-year development arc. Sherman’s philosophy is simple: if a young player has talent, your job isn’t to overhaul their motion — it’s to keep them durable and progressing.
- Prioritize stability and mobility over “more reps.”
- Encourage smart strength work and basic fitness habits.
- Keep multi-sport athletes engaged — athleticism transfers.
2) The 50–100 Yard Window Decides Seasons
Ask a roster what they need to improve and you’ll hear “driver consistency.” But if you want a faster path to lower team scoring, look inside 100 yards. Sherman emphasized that high school rounds are packed with partial wedges: layups on par fives, punch-outs from trouble, short-sided misses, and awkward distances after conservative strategy. If those shots are “uncomfortable,” the scorecard gets loud.
Make this zone a weekly priority — and your lineup stabilizes.
- 25–50 yard ladder drills (10/20/30/40/50) for touch and trajectory.
- 50–75 yard distance control reps with specific landing zones.
- Pressure wedges: “must hit the green” competitions to simulate match nerves.
3) Your “Bubble” Players Need the Most Coaching
Every program has them: the 7–10 players who are close enough to taste varsity but not secure enough to relax. Sherman calls them the “bubble boys” — golfers who feel like one bad nine holes means they’ve fallen off a cliff. They’re good enough to contribute, but often volatile under pressure because their identity gets tied to lineup position.
The fix starts with culture. Keep lineup spots fluid, emphasize readiness, and avoid turning “JV vs varsity” into an identity label. Many roster jumps aren’t about talent — they’re about emotional stability.
- Avoid locking identity to “JV” vs “Varsity.”
- Reward process and composure, not just one hot score.
- Create opportunities for 7–10 to be match-ready at any time.
4) Teach “No Mental Doubles”
A physical double bogey happens. A mental double is when one mistake turns into three. Sherman stressed that high school golf is often decided by response, not execution: the player who steadies after a bad shot beats the player who chases a hero recovery and compounds the damage.
Coaches can train this. Build routines for the moment after the mistake:
- Reset breath and tempo.
- Pick a conservative recovery target (fairway first).
- Commit to one shot — don’t negotiate with doubt.
- Limit big numbers by avoiding the second bad decision.
5) High School Golf Is a Unique Development Stage — Coach Accordingly
High school golf isn’t junior golf. It’s nine-hole pressure, school until mid-afternoon, limited daylight, and a team dynamic layered on top of an individual sport. Many athletes juggle other sports. Practice time is tight. The environment is emotional. Sherman’s approach is to prioritize efficiency and scoring skills — not volume.
- Run practices with targets, scoring games, and consequences.
- Practice “nine-hole mindset” — fast resets, no spirals.
- Build a culture where team energy supports individual performance.
6) Help Parents Understand What Actually Matters
Sherman believes scores matter for lineups — but they don’t tell the whole story. The best parent support doesn’t add pressure; it reinforces growth. A useful message for families: players can fully control two things — attitude and effort.
Encourage parents to ask better questions than “What did you shoot?”:
- “What was your favorite shot today?”
- “What did you learn?”
- “What’s one thing you want to work on tomorrow?”
7) Build the Whole Support System
The strongest developmental environments don’t rely on one person. Sherman’s view is that players benefit most when they have a support team: a swing coach, a simple strength plan, mental skills habits, nutrition awareness, and positive family backing. The high school coach’s role becomes a stabilizer — keeping players grounded, competitive, and moving forward.
The Big Takeaway
High school golf development isn’t about producing phenoms. It’s about creating durable athletes, stabilizing emotions, sharpening wedge control, and teaching players how to respond when the round turns. For many teams, the simplest formula holds up: stable beats spectacular, and process beats panic.
Most Popular Articles

Rory McIlroy Wins 2026 Seminole Pro-Member With Dad Gerry
Mar 2, 2026Rory McIlroy added another trophy to the mantle on golf’s most exclusive Monday, teaming with father Gerry at Seminole Golf Club.
U.S. Open Qualifying 2026: Local & Final Qualifying Sites for Shinnecock
Feb 19, 2026The road to Shinnecock Hills begins in April as 110 local qualifying sites and 13 final qualifying venues are set.
FINAL RESULTS: Gasparilla Invitational 2026
Feb 21, 2026Hayes Brown wins Gasparilla at 2-under, edging Peyton White by one, while Jeff Frazier claims the Senior title at Palma Ceia.
Michael McCoy Wins 2026 Jones Cup Senior Invitational at Sea Island
Feb 26, 20262026 Jones Cup Senior Invitational at Sea Island’s Seaside Course Final Results + Leaderboard
Top 10 Reasons to Compete at Sand Valley With Your Best Golf Partner in 2026
Feb 22, 2026Sand Valley makes ’26 the year for your best rivalry trip: five walkable links courses and big memories with your favorite partnerLoading latest news...
