Wellesley teen Broderick wins playoff at New England Amateur
July 23, 2020 | by Pete Wlodkowski of AmateurGolf.com
see also: John Broderick, View results for New England Amateur, GreatHorse Golf Club
After the two players tied at 4-under, Broderick edges month last week's Mass. Am runner-up Nick Maccario in extra holes
Nick Maccario has played some of the best golf of his career over the last two weeks, but fallen just short of securing major titles both times.
At the Massachusetts Amateur last week, (a match play event) Maccario, 28, knocked off three past champions including Matt Parziale on his way to the final match at The Kittansett Club. Despite playing the last 12 holes in 3-under -- "throwing the book at him," as he said at the time -- Maccario lost the Mass. Am final to Matt Organisak on the 36th hole.
Nick MaccarioToday at Concord Country Club, Maccario -- who won last year's Mass. Mid-Am by a whopping 15 shots -- posted his second straight 67 to grab the clubhouse lead, only to watch as 36-hole leader John Broderick was still on the course one shot behind with two to play.
“I was more nervous watching John finish than playing,” Maccario told the Mass. Golf Association. “The competition has been so great the last two weeks so it’s easy to get pumped up.” A birdie on No. 17, followed by a par at the last gave 36-hole leader Broderick a share of the lead, as the tournament was shortened to 54-holes due to weather delays in today's final round.
Broderick, after opening with the same score as Maccario (a 2-over 72), bounced back to post the low round of the tournament on Wednesday, a 65. During that magical round, the 16-year-old from Wellesley carded seven birdies, including four out of five from Hole Nos. 13-17 to take two stroke leading into today's final round, which was scheduled to be a full 36-holes.
After winning in extra holes, the young Broderick may have handed Maccario his second straight defeat, but nobody will argue that the Merrimack Valley resident is one of the elite players in the state. As for Broderick, he no doubt has collegiate golf in his future.
“It was unbelievable and crazy,” said Broderick, a junior at Belmont Hill School in an interview with the Mass. Golf Association. “It really shows that I’m at that level now," he continued. " I really improved so much in the last year. At the start of the year, I wasn’t really playing my best. I played the GolfWeek Junior Open last week and I really found something in my swing. Coming into this tournament, I felt really great. It really shows I can play with these guys and I can beat these guys.”
TOURNAMENT NOTES
The New England Amateur, which rotates each year to one of the six states in New England, was played this year at the historic Donald Ross-designed Concord Country Club. The course is located in the same town where the "shot heard round the world" was fired to start the Revolutionary War in 1775. The club's first nine holes designed by Ross opened for play in 1913, while the club itself dates back to 1895. Mature trees, and fescue-lined fairways give the course a distinctive look, while typically difficult Donald Ross greens make for some interesting pin placements and diabolical putts.
The New England Amateur winner gets their name on the Harry B. McCracken Jr. trophy, and this is the first time the tournament has been played since the legendary golf administrator passed in 2019. For 50 years – more than half of his adult life – the Massachusetts native was a dedicated volunteer to the Massachusetts Golf Association, New England Golf Association and the USGA. McCracken, the 2007 recipient of the USGA’s Joe Dey Award for meritorious service to the game, was a fixture for years at the New England Amateur.
At the Massachusetts Amateur last week, (a match play event) Maccario, 28, knocked off three past champions including Matt Parziale on his way to the final match at The Kittansett Club. Despite playing the last 12 holes in 3-under -- "throwing the book at him," as he said at the time -- Maccario lost the Mass. Am final to Matt Organisak on the 36th hole.
Nick Maccario
“I was more nervous watching John finish than playing,” Maccario told the Mass. Golf Association. “The competition has been so great the last two weeks so it’s easy to get pumped up.” A birdie on No. 17, followed by a par at the last gave 36-hole leader Broderick a share of the lead, as the tournament was shortened to 54-holes due to weather delays in today's final round.
John Broderick is 16-years-old, and needed par on his final hole of the tournament to force a playoff for the New England Amateur Championship.
— Mass Golf (@PlayMassGolf) July 24, 2020
What'd he do? Step up, flag it, and go chasing after it. 🏃♂️#TourSauce | @NoLayingUp pic.twitter.com/JR8lMH0K1J
Broderick, after opening with the same score as Maccario (a 2-over 72), bounced back to post the low round of the tournament on Wednesday, a 65. During that magical round, the 16-year-old from Wellesley carded seven birdies, including four out of five from Hole Nos. 13-17 to take two stroke leading into today's final round, which was scheduled to be a full 36-holes.
“It was unbelievable and crazy,” said Broderick, a junior at Belmont Hill School in an interview with the Mass. Golf Association. “It really shows that I’m at that level now," he continued. " I really improved so much in the last year. At the start of the year, I wasn’t really playing my best. I played the GolfWeek Junior Open last week and I really found something in my swing. Coming into this tournament, I felt really great. It really shows I can play with these guys and I can beat these guys.”
TOURNAMENT NOTES
The New England Amateur, which rotates each year to one of the six states in New England, was played this year at the historic Donald Ross-designed Concord Country Club. The course is located in the same town where the "shot heard round the world" was fired to start the Revolutionary War in 1775. The club's first nine holes designed by Ross opened for play in 1913, while the club itself dates back to 1895. Mature trees, and fescue-lined fairways give the course a distinctive look, while typically difficult Donald Ross greens make for some interesting pin placements and diabolical putts.
The New England Amateur winner gets their name on the Harry B. McCracken Jr. trophy, and this is the first time the tournament has been played since the legendary golf administrator passed in 2019. For 50 years – more than half of his adult life – the Massachusetts native was a dedicated volunteer to the Massachusetts Golf Association, New England Golf Association and the USGA. McCracken, the 2007 recipient of the USGA’s Joe Dey Award for meritorious service to the game, was a fixture for years at the New England Amateur.
Results: New England Amateur
| Place | Player | Location | Pts | Scores |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Wellesley, MA | 300 | 72-65-69=206 | |
| 2 | Waltham, MA | 200 | 72-67-67=206 | |
| 3 | Topsham, ME | 100 | 66-73-69=208 | |
| 4 | Swampscott, MA | 100 | 67-73-71=211 | |
| 5 | Rutland, VT | 100 | 72-71-69=212 |
About the New England Amateur
Held since 1926, the New England Amateur brings together players from six New England area states — Connecticut, Maine, Massachusetts, Vermont, New Hampshire, and Rhode Island. The event host rotates between each of the six represented states. The to...
Most Popular Articles
FINAL RESULTS: 2026 Australian Men’s Amateur Championship
Feb 6, 2026Billy Dowling pulled away with a closing 7-under 63 to win the 2026 adidas Australian Men’s Amateur Championship at 18-under.
Koivun powers Auburn to breakthrough Amer Ari victory
Feb 7, 2026Koivun’s 25-under week sparks Auburn’s record-setting win in Hawaii
2026 Ben Hogan Award Watch List: 35 Names to Know This Spring
Jan 29, 2026The 2026 Ben Hogan Award watch list is out—35 college golf standouts are in the early mix for the game’s top individual honor.
LIVE SCORING: 2026 Women's Amateur Asia-Pacific
Feb 13, 2026Women’s Amateur Asia-Pacific Returns — History, Opportunity, and a New Host in New Zealand
Titleist Fitting Philosophy: The Competitive Amateur’s Fastest Path to Lower Scores
Jan 26, 2026Competitive golf is a game of small edges. Titleist’s fitting approach combines expert human insight and honest data