Year	Team	Individual
2025	Methodist	Edward Coffren (Lynchburg)
2024	Methodist	Michael O'Sullivan (Oglethorpe)
2023	Carnegie Mellon	Josh Hebrink (Piedmont)
2022	Methodist	Andre Chi (Methodist)
2021	Illinois Wesleyan	Will Hocker (Webster)
2020	(cancelled)
2019	Methodist	Sam Goldenring (Williams)
2018	Methodist	Brian Peccie (Washington & Lee)
2017	Wittenberg	Josh Gibson (Hope College)
2016	Claremont-Mudd- Scripps	Evan Cox (Virginia Wesleyan)
2015	Methodist	Kelby Scharmann (La Verne)
2014	Schreiner	Bobby Holden (Redlands)
2013	Texas-Tyler	Brad Shigezawa (Claremont-Mudd-Scripps)
2012	Oglethorpe	Anthony Maccaglia (Oglethorpe)
2011	Greensboro	Chris Morris (Centre)
2010	Methodist	Tain Lee (Claremont–Mudd–Scripps)
2009	Oglethorpe	Olafur Loftsson (Oglethorpe)
2008	St. John's (MN)	Clinton Dammann (Saint John's)
2007	St. John's (MN)	Scott Harris, Jr. (St. John Fisher)
2006	Nebraska Wesleyan	Stephen Goodridge (Rochester)
2005	Guilford	Colin Clark (Guilford)
2004	Gustavus Adolphus	Chad Poling (Ohio Wesleyan)
2003	Averett	Janne Mommo (Averett)
2002	Guilford	Chris Noll (Wesley)
2001	Wisconsin–Eau Claire	Chad Collins (Methodist)
2000	Greensboro	Kevin O'Connell (Greensboro)
1999	Methodist	Chad Collins (Methodist)
1998	Methodist	Chad Collins (Methodist)
1997	Methodist	Brion McLaughlin (Methodist)
1996	Methodist	Mike Adamson (Methodist)
1995	Methodist	Ryan Jenkins (Methodist)
1994	Methodist	Scott Scovil (Christopher Newport)
1993	UC San Diego	Ryan Jenkins (Methodist)
1992	Methodist	Jon Lindquist (Gustavus Adolphus)
1991	Methodist	Lee Palms (Emory)
1990	Methodist	Rob Pilewski (Methodist)
1989	Cal State Stanislaus	John McCullough (Methodist)
1988	Cal State Stanislaus	Glenn Andrade (Cal State Stanislaus)
1987	Cal State Stanislaus	Pat Weishan (UC San Diego)
1986	Cal State Stanislaus	Eric Meerbach (WPI)
1985	Stanislaus State	Brian Goldsworthy (Central)
1984	Stanislaus State	Bob Osborne (Redlands)
1983	Allegheny	Matt Clarke (Allegheny)
1982	Ramapo	Cliff Smith (Stanislaus State)
1981	Stanislaus State	Ryan Fox (UNC Greensboro)
1980	Stanislaus State	Mike Bender (Stanislaus State)
1979	Stanislaus State	Mike Bender (Stanislaus State)
1978	Stanislaus State	Jim Quinn (Oswego State)
1977	Stanislaus State	David Downing (Southeastern Massachusetts)
1976	Stanislaus State	Dan Lisle (Stanislaus State)
1975	Wooster	Charles Baskervill (Hampden–Sydney)